Jose Cincinnatus McKenzie, II was born in 1953 in the United Kingdom of Canadian Father and a Filipina mother. Under Canadian laws, JC's mother automatically became a Canadian national by marriage. In 1973, upon reaching the age of majority, JC elected to acquire Philippine Citizenship. However, JC continued to reside in Ottawa and carried a Canadian Passport. He also paid allegiance to Canadian Crown, In 2010, he was elected Senator. One of his opponent moved to disqualify him on the grounds that;

Questions:
A. He was not a natural born citizen;
B. He had dual allegiance not only in the Philippines but also to Canada.